Five Best Cinnamon Rolls

Nothing tastes better during the cold of winter than a little warming cinnamon. We like to get our cinnamon fix in the form of an ooey-gooey, fresh-from-the-oven cinnamon roll. We found the five tastiest cinnamon rolls in 417-land, from a super-huge homemade version tucked away inside a coffee shop to a farmers’ market find that’s heavy on softness and spice. Read on, and pick your favorite.

1. AmyCakes
$1.99, 308 W. McDaniel St.,
Springfield, sweetsbyamycakes.com
Why we love it: These are huge: Probably 2 inches tall and quite expansive. They have a great cinnamon flavor and are plenty sticky, but they aren’t too gooey. And although they are quite sweet, the cinnamon roll dough has a nice yeasty, buttery flavor that adds a real homemade taste to the roll. These cinnamon rolls are big enough to share, but you’ll want to unroll each soft layer and savor every single bite yourself.

2. Artisan’s Oven
$2.75, 1832 S. Ingram Mill Rd., Springfield
Why we love it:  These are a little smaller than some of the other cinnamon rolls on the list, and they are irregularly shaped in the most charming way. The cinnamon filling is liberally applied, making these extra-cinnamony. In fact, the dark cinnamon-sugar that rests between the soft layers of dough has an almost caramelized flavor. There’s just the tiniest layer of sweet white icing on top, and the edges of the cinnamon roll have a satisfying crunchiness that adds a nice contrast to the soft center.

3. Old Mill Bagel Co.  
Available at multiple 417-land locations.
Why we love it:  These are just so stinking good. The roll is super-soft and slightly chewy. (Full disclosure: I poked every plastic-wrapped roll until I found the softest one.) The cinnamon filling is plentiful and incredibly, wonderfully, deliciously gooey. And it’s not overly sugary. Rather, it’s extra-cinnamony, making the ratio a more grown-up flavor. I ate it straight from the farmers’ market table after I bought it, but I would imagine these are extra-good out of the oven or warmed up in the microwave. Based in Fair Grove, Old Mill Bagel Co. doesn’t have a storefront. But the company’s baked goods are sold at Bistro Market, Home Grown Food Store, MaMa Jean’s, the Greater Springfield Farmers’ Market and other local farmers’ markets.

Want more foodie news? Sign up for Table Talk here!

4. Elle’s Patisserie
$2.50, 1454 E. Cherry St., Springfield,
ellespatisserie.com
Why we love it: It’s big and round and beautifully brown. It’s a pretty, perfect coil, with the center rising up higher than the edges. Those outer edge layers are a little bit flaky, and the center layers are moist and soft and chewy. The cinnamon between the layers, although not terribly thick, is delicious and full of flavor. Plus, there’s sweet white icing that nearly covers the top but is applied thinly enough that it doesn’t overwhelm the rest of the roll.

5. The Buzz
$2.15, 2810 E. Battlefield, Springfield
Why we love it:  This cinnamon roll is one of the best-smelling on the list. It has a yeasty fresh-baked-bread aroma (the kind we want wafting though our homes every day forever), accented with sweetness. We love the icing, too, because it’s super-gooey but not too sweet for the buttery cinnamon-y goodness in between each soft layer of the roll’s coil.
 

More Articles Like This

5 Best Fall Fests

This month starts fall festival season in 417-land, and it seems like every little town in our region has something to celebrate.

Farmers Cooking Class

The second Farmers Cooking Class features a gourmet three-course meal, wine pairings and plenty of tips for cooking with the seasons—and you’re invited to attend.

417 Restaurant Month Boulevard Beer Dinner

Like us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Sign up for our newsletters Follow us on Instagram

  1. The Wheelhouse
    Located in Springfield’s food truck park, The Wheelhouse offers fresh Mexican-Thai fusion...
  2. Cooking Class: Farmers Gastropub
    This month, we welcome chef Peter Tinson and Farmers Gastropub owner Bill Griffiths to the kitchen.
  3. 5 Best Fall Fests
    This month starts fall festival season in 417-land, and it seems like every little town in our...
  4. Vasken’s Deli
    Vasken’s Deli is known for its killer gyros, but it serves up another pita sandwich that has...
  5. Strawberry-Basil Sangria
    There’s nothing like a nice glass of sangria to sweeten your meal, especially when it’s still...