Best Italian Restaurants

On the following pages, we profile 417-land’s very best Italian restaurants. You’ll find chefs from Italy, and tips for what to order when you visit their restaurants..

By Savannah Waszczuk Photos by Kevin 0'Riley

Nov 2012

Here in 417-land, we love homemade, freshly prepared Italian cuisine. We love plates loaded with tender spaghetti and topped with juicy, hand-formed meatballs. We love homemade fettuccine tossed with Alfredo, and those ravioli that have been hand-stuffed with so much filling that they’re about to pop. Our mouths water at the thought of fresh focaccia dipped in olive oil. That’s why we went out in search of the best Italian flavors in southwest Missouri.

On the following pages, we profile 417-land’s very best Italian restaurants. You’ll find chefs from Italy, and tips for what to order when you visit their restaurants. We tell you where to find things like homemade ricotta cheese pasta, tiramisu, mouthwatering marinara and drool-worthy cream sauce, plus the very best Italian cooking ingredients and how to try them out in your own kitchen. Tossed with a little love and sprinkled with some Parmesan, this is a pasta-perfect feature that will fill your belly and warm your heart. 


306 South Ave., Springfield, 417-831-1222; 3512 S. National Ave., Springfield, 417-890-8300, nonnascafe.com

A  year ago, Shawn Kraft hopped on a plane, flew over the Atlantic and took a culinary tour of Italy, eating every delicious dish he could get his hands on. After nine days of tasty travels, he headed back to 417-land with a brain full of original recipes to share. As a result of the epicurean adventure, menu changes occurred at both the downtown Nonna’s Italian Café location that Kraft owns and the southside Nonna’s location that he co-owns with Allison Kraft. “We started playing with risottos more, and we changed the way we focus on the pasta itself,” Kraft says, hinting that there’s much more to cooking spaghetti than throwing it into boiling water. “We also pulled a lot of the sauces back to the traditional recipes,” he says. “We pulled everything back to its roots.”

Before you dig into the entrée selections at Nonna’s, you’ll be dipping fresh bread in olive oil and piling it with freshly chopped garlic and Parmesan cheese—the restaurant’s well-known bread service. The menu provides your own tour of Italy, with meats, veggies and polentas inspired by the Northern Italian region and pastas with tomato-based marinaras and pomodoros inspired by the South. A couple of months ago, the restaurant delved into coastal Italian offerings, adding redfish and stuffed calamari tubes (filled with Italian sausage and polenta).

No matter what you order, know that chefs use authentic cooking methods. The marsala sauce is the real deal. “It takes half a bottle of wine to make one person’s dish,” Kraft says. A sauce of nothing but wine, garlic and butter? We’ll see you at dinner.

One More Reason to Love It: The Parmesan cheese comes from a 25-pound wheel that they grate daily. Talk about fresh!




Executive chef Joseph Smith pulls the ai caprini e peperoni out of the brick pizza oven at Bruno’s Italian Restaurant.

416 South Ave., Springfield, 417-866-0007, dineatbrunos.com

Bruno’s Italian Restaurant is tucked away on downtown Springfield’s South Avenue in a beautifully restored historic building. Philodendrons hang from the ceiling, and a mural of Bruno’s Italian vineyard and house is painted on the north-side wall. Not too long after you’re seated in the quaint eatery, you’re delivered freshly baked focaccia bread and a delicious dipping sauce made of sun-dried tomatoes, olive oil and balsamic vinegar. You’ll be dragging the focaccia across the plate to soak up every last drop. 

You’ll often spot chef Joseph Smith or even owner Bruno Gargiulo himself in the kitchen area just behind the bar, as they toss together pasta dishes or heave pizzas into the brick oven. Gargiulo was born and raised in Palermo, Sicily, then came to the United States in 2003. He opened Bruno’s in 2005. There you can grab both lunch and dinner, with the lunch menu offering a smaller selection of soups, salads, panini, meat, fish, pasta and pizza. 

“All of our breads are made on the premises,” Gargiulo says. This also goes for the restaurant’s sauces, desserts and even the Sicilian sausage. Popular dishes include the rigatoni al ragu di carne, a rigatoni pasta served with traditional meat ragu sauce; and an angel hair pasta dish that’s prepared with sun-dried tomatoes, garlic, fresh basil and chili oil. 

In addition to pasta, Bruno’s Italian Restaurant serves chicken, beef and seafood entrées, and specials often include fish that’s flown in from the Mediterranean Sea and the Pacific Ocean. And the pizzas here are fabulous. The brick oven makes the crust the perfect combo of crispy and chewy, and there’s just the right amount of mozzarella to make it string from your mouth after each sinfully delicious bite. Toppings aren’t overbearing, but they’re enough to add a zip of flavor to every mouthful. (We love the pepperoni pie that’s dotted with salty, briny olives.)  

One More Reason to Love It:

Bruno Gargiulo has a vineyard in Sicily, and you can order some of his vino at the restaurant. The spot recently started serving the vineyard’s third vintage wine, which is a blend of 65 percent cabernet and 35 percent merlot.


2708 S. Glenstone Ave., Springfield, 417-883-3403, nearlyfamous.net

When a restaurant has the word “pasta” in its name, it better be ready to serve up some first-class entrées. Nearly Famous Deli & Pasta House does not disappoint. The pasta menu here includes spaghetti marinara, baked lasagna, spinach lasagna and fettuccine Alfredo at lunch, and the dinner menu expands to include tortellini, chicken cacciatore, and veal Parmesan and more. A favorite here is the chicken piccatta dinner special—a lightly breaded chicken breast topped with a delectable sauce of capers, lemon juice and chicken stock. If you’re craving seafood, try out the Italian shrimp, a flavorful combo of shrimp, celery, garlic, bell peppers and scallions tossed with spaghetti, garlic, butter and Parmesan. The restaurant makes all of its sauces from scratch, and the staff whips up some tasty homemade meatballs. 

One More Reason to Love It: Pasta entrées here include a dinner salad or a cup of deli tomato soup. (People love this soup!)


3014 S. National Ave., Springfield, 417-889-9898, darpinositaliancafe.com

At D’Arpino’s Italian Café, the marinara sauce is the perfect blend of sweet and spicy. “My joke is that’s why I married my husband—his marinara,” says Mary Ann D’Arpino, who owns the restaurant with her husband, Mark. The couple opened the intimate Italian restaurant in 2004. Its menu offers pastas, pizzas (that you can order with Alfredo sauce), sandwiches and desserts. Among the most popular dishes is the Penne Valentine with penne pasta, garlic, grilled chicken, sun-dried tomatoes, fresh spinach, bacon and Alfredo. On the weekends, specials often include grilled Italiano pork chops and Parmesan-encrusted grilled tilapia with shrimp. “We try to put an Italian flair on everything,” D’Arpino says. 

One More Reason to Love It: Try the calzone that’s jam-packed with ham, salami, provolone, capicola, prosciutto, mozzarella, ricotta and veggies. It’s called the Balboa Delight. Yo, Adrian! 


1908 S. Glenstone Ave., Springfield, 417-567-3463, avanzareitaliandining.com

Avanzare Italian Dining doesn’t open until dinner time, but chef and owner Tony Garcia puts on his apron much earlier to bake fresh bread, cut steaks and even prepare hand-made pasta for a couple of the spot’s signature dishes, including the Pasta Alla Tony. To create a dish worthy of his namesake, Garcia tosses the fresh-made pasta with tender, grilled chicken, portobello mushrooms, basil, marinara and an unbeatable brandy tomato cream sauce. Also named after the chef himself is the Rigatoni Alla Tony, a mouthwatering dish of shrimp, sun-dried tomatoes, roasted walnuts and rigatoni pasta topped with goat cheese and served in a pesto cream sauce. (Drooling yet?)

Other stars on the Northern Tuscany–inspired menu include the seafood-filled frutti di mare entrée, featuring spaghetti, shrimp, calamari, scallops, black mussels, fresh marinara and a touch of red pepper. Another favorite is the bistecca rosemarino, a ribeye that’s hand-cut by Garcia and topped with a white wine and gorgonzola cheese sauce. But before you even order one of these flavor-packed menu pleasers, you’ll enjoy some pre-carb carbs via a lovely little bread basket filled with house-made focaccia bread and baguettes that you can slather with a hefty serving of the restaurant’s mixed Italian herb and garlic butter.

The mood is intimate, making the restaurant a perfect spot for a date night or special family gathering, and the food is all made to order, so you know you’ll chow down on a piping-hot plate of pasta.

One More Reason to Love It: At press time, Garcia told us that a new menu was in the works—and it includes three house-made raviolis! 



1647 E. Sunshine St., Springfield, 417-887-1778, queencitydeli.com

Whether you’re looking to dine out or want to cook like an Italian chef at home, Queen City Deli is the place to be. The restaurant-grocery hybrid offers both delicious dine-in Italian cuisine and a variety of hard-to-find Italian ingredients you can take home to prepare your own feast. Long-time 417-landers may recognize owner Jay Parrino from his former restaurant, J. Parrino’s. If you ever ate there, you will see a few familiar dishes on Queen City’s menu.

The Italian sandwich selection here offers plenty of opportunity for indulgence. For example, the Parrino Special piles a hefty stack of roast beef, Italian salami and prosciutto on garlic cheese bread and tops it with the restaurant’s house salad (drool!). Former Chicagoans often say the restaurant’s Italian beef sandwich is the closest thing they’ve had to sandwiches served in the Windy City. But there are also a handful of pasta entrées that should not be overlooked. A favorite is the baked mostaccioli, a penne pasta entrée that features red and white sauces and is smothered in cheese. Other dishes feature stuffed pastas and Italian sausages that are made on The Hill, the Italian neighborhood in St. Louis where Parrino grew up. 

One More Reason to Love It: The grocery area here sells San Marzano tomatoes, imported pastas, cannoli shells, Arborio rice (for making risotto) and Italian lunch meats. Tie on your apron, and get busy!


2259 S. Campbell Ave., Springfield, 417-882-5166, digiacintos.com

Sam DiGiacinto grew up in an Italian neighborhood in Atlantic City, New Jersey. “There were four Italian bakeries,” DiGiacinto says. “It was filled with families that came over from Italy.” DiGiacinto recreates many of those authentic Italian recipes from his childhood every day, then he serves them to salivating 417-landers at DiGiacinto Italian Restaurant. The magic here starts with the homemade Italian bread, which comes with the lunch and dinner entrées. It’s that crispy-chewy on the outside, soft on the inside, for-real Italian stuff that’s really hard to come by in southwest Missouri. Favorite pasta dishes here include the lasagna, Alfredo dishes and spaghetti and homemade meatballs, and the restaurant has Philly cheesesteak subs that provide some serious competition to cheesesteaks served in the city of brotherly love itself. (Sam’s dad owned a sub shop in Atlantic City, so he knows what he’s doing.)

One More Reason to Love It: From 2:30–6 p.m., you can order a “lunch special” from any day of the week (and it comes with salad and bread) for $10. 




1. Gorgonzola 

Gorgonzola is a blue-veined cheese made from cow’s milk. It has a creamy texture and a slightly pungent, rich flavor.  Where to get it: Any supermarket, such as Hy-Vee, Price Cutter, or Harter House

Try it: Paired with a good steak


2. Mozzarella 

Mozzarella is often made from cow’s milk, but there’s also a variety made from water buffalo’s milk. The cheese is well known as a pizza topper, and the fresh variety features a softer texture and more delicate flavor than the factory-made kind. Where to get it: Any local supermarket 

Try it: Fresh from a mozzarella ball, cut into thick slices and sprinkled with sea salt 


3. Fontina

This cheese is semi-soft, sweet and boasts a nutty flavor. It’s great for melting, and the longer it’s aged, the richer the flavor. Where to get it: Any local supermarket with a good cheese selection

Try it: Melted with Parmesan into homemade Alfredo sauce


4. Ricotta

This cheese is most often made from cow’s milk and typically features a slightly grainy texture and mildly sweet flavor. It’s often available in whole milk and part-skim varieties. Where to get it: Any supermarket, or locally made from Lorenae Dairy 

Try it: Blended with fresh spinach and stuffed into chicken breasts


5. Asiago 

Asiago cheese is a semi-hard to hard cheese that’s filled with tiny holes. It has rich flavor and creamy texture, and as it ages, it becomes firmer and is easily grated. Where to get it: Any local supermarket with a good cheese selection 

Try it: Shredded and baked on top of a loaf of fresh bread

6. Mascarpone 

This cheese has a super-rich flavor that tastes like a cross between whipped butter and cream cheese. It's often used in desserts. Where to get it: Any local supermarket with a good cheese selection

Try it: Spread a little onto some delicate crackers


7. Provolone 

Varieties of provolone aged less than two months are delicate and creamy, while longer-aged varieties often have a spicy, sharp flavor. Where to get it: Any local supermarket with a good cheese selection

Try it: Grilled with fresh veggies on your favorite bread 


8. Parmesan 

Parmesan is a slightly generic American term for hard, dry, sharp-flavored Italian cheese that is suitable for grating. The authentic cheese that inspired the word is produced in a region near Parma, Italy and named Parmigiano-Reggiano, which is the highest quality of Parmesan cheese produced. Parmesan is known for its complex flavor and sharp, nutty taste. Where to get it: Any local supermarket with a good cheese selection

Try it: Sprinkled on freshly popped popcorn—or atop just about every Italian dish. 


9. Romano 

Romano is a hard, salty Italian cheese that’s made from sheep’s milk and is great for grating.  Where to get it: Any local supermarket with a good cheese selection

Try it: Grated and blended into your favorite homemade meatball recipe



820 E. Walnut St., Springfield, 417-862-6400,  gilardis.com

Perhaps one of the most charming things about dining at Gilardi’s Ristorante is talking to Nicola Gilardi himself, who often comes out of the kitchen to chat with customers. You’ll love his accent, which he brought over from Italy along with a collection of delectable recipes and top-notch cooking skills. (Editor's note: Since the publication of this article, Nicola Gilardi has sold Gilardi's to James Martin.)

Born and raised in Italy, Gilardi helped out in his family’s restaurant from childhood all the way until he was old enough to attend an Italian culinary school. (Now that’s authentic.) Since he completed his training, he has worked in fine-dining restaurants all around the globe. In 1998, Gilardi and his wife, Monica, opened Gilardi’s Ristorante in Springfield, giving him a chance to serve 417-landers top-notch Italian creations from a dimly lit, cozy carriage house tucked away on Walnut Street. 

The menu at Gilardi’s includes primarily Northern Italian cuisine, loyal to Gilardi’s roots. One of the spot’s most popular dishes is the signature Gilardi Pasta, a meal of homemade ricotta cheese pasta (hand-made at the restaurant) with mushrooms and Italian sausage in a lightly spiced tomato cream sauce. The homemade pasta is the real star in the dish, offering an unbeatable rich flavor and a firm texture. The light homemade sauce, fresh mushrooms and hunks of savory sausage are just a bonus. Regular customers also love the osso buco—a stewed veal shank and mushrooms dish served with polenta. The spot also serves wheat pasta and gluten-free entrées on request, and meat-hungry diners have their choice of center-cut filets served with green peppercorn or gorgonzola cream sauce. “I only buy the center cuts, so everyone is happy,” Gilardi says. Thanks to the cooking skills of Gilardi and sous chef Ramone Barrios, this happiness is easy to come by. 

If you’re in the mood for alcohol, the restaurant offers an impressive list of wines, and Gilardi often makes his own limoncello (a lemon-flavored Italian liqueur). The stuff is stout, refreshing and served in a fancy little cordial glass, making a delicious after-dinner treat. Salute! 


One More Reason to Love It: Even if it’s not on the menu, Gilardi will make you whatever you’re in the mood to eat (if the restaurant is not too busy). “We are always here to serve the customer,” Gilardi says. 




Lifestyle Editor Savannah Waszczuk tries her hand at making pasta from scratch with Avanzare’s head chef and owner Tony Garcia. Garcia shares a few tips for making your own Italian feast.


Pasta can be flavored and colored with a variety of ingredients, such as beets, tomato paste, pesto, spinach or saffron. Just combine your additive with the liquid ingredients before you combine them with the semolina and flour.

When making your dough, mix until it has a consistent color throughout. If your mixture seems dry, add water one tablespoon at a time until it becomes pliable.

All you need to make ravioli is a wine glass! After you roll a large sheet of pasta, cut it into two pieces, one slightly larger than the other. Place the smaller sheet on a counter top, and form circle shapes on the dough with the rim of a wine glass. Add a tablespoon of your desired filling inside of each circle, then brush around the outside of the circle with a well-beaten egg. Place the larger sheet of pasta on top, then lightly press down around each filled ravioli. Seal and cut the ravioli apart with the rim of the wine glass.

If you’re angry, consider making some homemade pasta—Garcia says kneading the dough is a great stress reliever!

Garcia’s basic pasta recipe (online at 417mag.com) can be used for noodles, ravioli or lasagna. Garcia says if you’re making ravioli, roll it very thin, allowing the filling to play an equal role.


Basic Pasta Recipe 


1 1/8 pounds semolina, plus extra for dusting
1 3/5 pounds all-purpose flour  
¼ cup olive oil
4 eggs
Water, room temperature

To Prepare: 

Place semolina and flour in a large mixing bowl, and mix with hands until well combined. In a large measuring cup, break eggs, add oil, then add water until you have two cups of liquid. If you have a stand mixer, load the dough hook and mix semolina, flour and eggs together until well combined. If you do not have a stand mixer, place the semolina and flour mixture on a countertop in the shape of a mountain. Form a well in the center of the semolina and flour mixture, then pour in the egg mixture. Using a fork, slowly incorporate the flour with the eggs by mixing, adding more flour to the center as the mixture combines. Keep mixing until the ingredients are all incorporated. 

After the dough is formed, dust a countertop with semolina and knead it for approximately five minutes. After kneading, separate dough in half, wrap each half in plastic wrap and let rest for 10 minutes. Working with one half at a time, roll the dough into a flat rectangular shape with a rolling pin. If you have a pasta machine, adjust it on the widest setting and roll the dough through three or four times. Next, move the setting down one notch and pass dough through once. Continue lowering the setting and rolling dough through (once per setting) until pasta reaches desired thickness. If you do not have a pasta machine, you will have to roll dough as thin as possible with a rolling pin. (It’s very hard to get the pasta thin without a pasta machine. You can purchase a pasta machine at a variety of local stores, such as Everything Kitchens, 2750 South Glenstone Ave., Springfield, where prices start at $59.99.) After dough reaches desired thickness, use pasta machine or a pizza cutter to cut it into noodles. Dip fresh-cut noodles in semolina to prevent sticking. 

Note: This recipe makes approximately 8 six-ounce servings of pasta. Pasta can be wrapped in plastic, frozen and prepared at a later date.



2690 Green Mountain Drive, Branson, 417-337-9882,  florentinasristoranteitaliano.com

The lemon white wine cream sauce at Florentina’s Ristorante Italiano helps set the restaurant apart. Made of lemon juice, white wine and heavy cream, this fresh yet savory sauce is served in a variety of classic pasta dishes, including the Capellini Vongole that combines pasta, clams, garlic and parsley. All the sauces here are made from scratch, as well as the bread, meatballs and cannoli. The restaurant’s massive menu offers everything from a Nachos Italiano appetizer (think loaded, crispy pasta chips) to seafood, steaks and house specialties such as slow-roasted Tuscan ribs. The restaurant also serves brick-oven pizzas, including a Sallsiccia Con Mela with Italian sausage, sliced apples and candied walnuts that are made in-house. A customer favorite is the Rigatoni Florentina dish that combines grilled chicken, mushrooms, onions, broccoli, artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes, fresh basil, parsley, capers, kalamata olives, garlic and rigatoni in a tomato cream sauce (holy moly!). If you’re out with the family, you can enjoy dining family-style here, sharing platters of appetizers, salads, soups, pasta dishes and specialties. Pass the spaghetti! 


One More Reason to Love It: Florentina’s Ristorante Italiano tops many dishes with a signature cheese blend that combines provolone, mozzarella, fontina and two kinds of Parmesan. 



218 S. Main St., Joplin, 417-626-8111, caldones.com

(Editor's note: This restaurant has closed since the publication of this article.)

If you dine at this Joplin restaurant on the weekend, you won’t only enjoy scrumptious Italian food—you’ll also enjoy live blues music played on a harmonica. The live music adds to the restaurant’s cozy and welcoming ambiance, making it the perfect spot to share a romantic meal or enjoy a family dinner. Owner Donnie Bennett just launched a new fall menu. Caldone’s is known for making its own pasta, and many Joplin residents enjoy the lunchtime buffet that includes pizza. At dinner time, guests can indulge in bread with roasted garlic, balsamic vinegar and olive oil, and meat-lovers enjoy the Three Wise Guys entrée that features three filets served on garlic mashed potatoes. One’s topped with a crab cake, one with a scallop and one with shrimp, and each has an accompanying sauce. A favorite pasta dish is Caldone’s Chanel No. 5, a dish of lobster, shrimp, artichokes, prosciutto and cheese tortellini in a garlic cream sauce. 


One More Reason to Love It: The restaurant prepares a few dishes tableside, including a flaming Parmesan cheese appetizer and a bananas foster dessert. 

1141 E. Delmar St., Springfield, 417-862-9999, 2810 E Battlefield Rd, Springfield, MO 65804, 417-881-4442, bambinoscafe.com

With its cozy building located just a quick walk from Missouri State University, Bambino’s Café gets a lot of love from college kids. But they’re not the only ones who adore this cozy restaurant. Since opening in 2000, Bambino’s has earned a respectable rep as a casual neighborhood restaurant that offers tasty food at affordable prices. The menu is just the right size with a nice selection of panini, pastas, personal pizzas, fresh salads and homemade soups. Andy Faucett owns the restaurant with his mother, Mary. In addition to soups, they make all of the restaurant’s breads and sauces. One favorite is the baked ziti dish. To make the sauce, they braise a beef roast for hours, then combine the robust stock with a tasty tomato sauce and wine. It’s then tossed with pasta and a little cream, and the result is a dish so tasty you won’t be able to stop eating it. Frequent diners also love the panini sandwiches, which are giant in both size and flavor. For dessert, try the homemade tiramisu or the gelato from Springfield’s Benissimo Gelato and Sorbet. 

One More Reason to Love It: When it’s nice outside, dine on the patio. Tucked away in the Phelps Grove neighborhood, it almost feels like you’re eating on your own porch!


3631 E. Sunshine St., Springfield, 417-886-3700

In 2010, 417-land chef Nicola Gilardi of Gilardi’s Ristorante made the other half of his name famous. Gilardi and his wife, Monica, opened Nicola’s Ristorante, a gem of an Italian restaurant on East Sunshine Street. “The food is similar, but it’s a different ambiance,” Gilardi says as he compares his two restaurants. “I’d say Nicola’s is more fine dining casual, and Gilardi’s is more fine dining cozy.” 

Nicola’s has a large bar area, and Gilardi was working on expanding it at press time. “It will be almost twice as big,” he says. The spacious bar makes Nicola’s a popular spot for post-work drinks, where people can kick back with house cocktails such as the Genoa, an Italian-inspired vodkatini; and the Grappa di Galliano, a cocktail of Gaja Grappa, lemon and orange juice with a Galliano rinse. 

Guests often end up sticking around for dinner, where they can order from mouthwatering menu items or five to six fish specials each night. “It depends on what we can get fresh,” Gilardi says. That’s also why the restaurant’s popular seafood pasta entrée changes up a bit. “It’s usually linguini noodles, olive oil, garlic, a splash of tomato sauce, crushed red pepper, black mussels, jumbo shrimp and jumbo scallops, calamari and white mushrooms,” Gilardi says. “But based on freshness, it sometimes has clams, crawfish or other seafood.” Other favorites here include the penne alla vodka, penne noodles in light spicy tomato cream sauce with chicken and a splash of vodka; and the veal and portobello mushroom ravioli, hand-stuffed pasta served in a cream sauce and drizzled with truffle oil.

One More Reason to Love It: There’s a handful of delicious homemade desserts to try at this restaurant, including a special cannoli with Nutella filling! 



Any time Italian cuisine is mentioned at the Whitaker Publishing offices, we end up debating one very important question: Which veal and portobello mushroom ravioli dish reigns supreme—the one at Ristorante Gilardi’s or the one at Bruno’s Italian Restaurant? The two pack some hefty competition, but the food feud has never truly been settled behind our closed doors. At least not until now. To put a stop to the madness, we sent one brave, starving, not-too-proud lifestyle editor to eat the dishes for dinner, one immediately after the other. What occurred was an ambrosial adventure tasting these two hand-stuffed wonders (and it left this editor with some really tight pants).

*Disclaimer: Both of these dishes are sinfully delicious, and the rankings are based solely on personal opinion. If you like good Italian food, we can guarantee one thing: Both of these entrées will provide you with love at first bite.

Ristorante Gilardi’s

The dish: The “ravioli of the day,” a veal and portobello mushroom ravioli served in cream sauce and drizzled with truffle oil, $18.95

Overall flavor: ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

Filling (ratio of stuffing to pasta): ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

Accompanying sauce: ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

First look: Holy cow. This dish is loaded with mushrooms. I can’t pick up my fork fast enough.

Two-minute review: The second this plate of hand-made magic was set in front of me, I immediately smelled the truffle oil. I was excited, to say the least. The waiter kindly and calmly offered to sprinkle my dish with fresh Parmesan, and I happily accepted. And then I quickly shooed him away, so I could chow down like a starving mad woman. At first bite, I wanted to sing. I wanted to dance. I wanted to scream from the top of a mountain. The flavor of the filling is truly unlike anything I’ve ever tasted. It’s finely ground, beyond tender and offers a richness and creaminess that cannot be rivaled with typical beef. And there are jumbo hunks of mushroom mixed in, providing a welcome consistency change. The cream sauce here is a light complement, not too overbearing, letting the true flavor of the veal-mushroom filling shine. And Gilardi’s certainly doesn’t skimp with the truffle oil—I got some of that rich flavor with every bite. After I gobbled down every last morsel, I wondered one thing: Can I take a bath in that filling?


Bruno’s Italian Restaurant

The dish: Ravioli di Vitello e Funghi Portobello (veal and portobello mushroom ravioli with mushroom sauce and truffle oil), $14.90

Overall flavor: ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

Filling (ratio of stuffing to pasta): ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

Accompanying sauce:  ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

First look: Whoa, that’s a whole lot of food!

Two-minute review: As soon as my entrée was served, I excitedly counted each ravioli like kids count their gifts on Christmas morning. One, two, three, four, five, six, seven! This dish came with seven giant ravioli, which is one more than I was served at Gilardi’s. But after my first bite, I did notice one thing—there was a bit less filling than Gilardi’s pillowy treats. But that filling is ridiculously delicious and richer than Donald Trump. And that sauce. Oh, that beefy, mushroomy sauce. It’s beyond delish, and they give you a lot of it. I would say it might even compete with the ravioli as the star of the meal. There’s not quite as much truffle flavor, but the complex, salty bite of the mushroom sauce pairs with the delicate pasta and tender filling to create a party for the tastebuds. This dish definitely gets two thumbs up.